Italian Pizza Vs American Pizza: What are The Differences?

Rate this post

When it comes to pizza, there’s no denying that the Italians and Americans have two very different takes on this beloved dish. While Italian pizza is typically cooked in a wood-fired oven with thin crusts and simple toppings, American pizza is often cooked in an electric oven with thick crusts and piled high with various toppings. So how do these two styles of pizza compare? Let’s take a look at Italian Pizza vs American Pizza!Italian Pizza Vs American Pizza

Italian pizza vs American pizza: main differences?

There are some key differences between traditional Italian pizza and American pizza:

Crust – Italian pizza crust tends to be thin and crisp while American pizza crust tends to be thicker, softer and chewier. Italian crust is often baked at higher temperatures to achieve the classic thin, crunchy texture.

Toppings – Italian pizza usually has a more simplistic topping selection focusing on quality fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, olives and herbs. American pizza often has a wider variety of toppings including meats, vegetables and different cheeses.

Sauce – The pizza sauce used on Italian pizza is typically lighter in color, sweeter and more herb-focused with ingredients like oregano and basil. American pizza sauce tends to be thicker, tangier and less herbaceous.

Cheese – Italian pizza features fresh mozzarella cheese that is light, milky and softens slightly when baked. American pizza tends to use shredded mozzarella or a cheese blend that leads to a morestringy, bread-like texture.

Size – Italian pizzas are usually much smaller in diameter, between 8 to 12 inches. American pizzas tend to be larger, ranging from 12 to over 24 inches.

Overall, Italian pizzas emphasize simplicity, quality ingredients and a thin, crispy crust, while American pizzas tend to offer more variety, cheese-loaded toppings and a thicker, soft crust.

Authentic Italian pizzas focus on highlighting the tastes of the fine ingredients, especially the cheese and sauce, which are used more sparingly. The toppings often play a supporting role. In contrast, American pizza emphasizes abundance of toppings and cheese with an emphasis on heartiness and filling satisfaction.

How did pizza evolve in Italy vs America?

The evolution of pizza differed in Italy and America in several ways:

In Italy:

• Pizza originated in Naples in the 18th or 19th century as a simple dish of bread, tomato sauce and toppings for poor residents.

• It remained a street food and modest dish through the early 20th century, made with high-quality, fresh ingredients but simple preparations.

• After World War II, pizza became more popular with the rise of pizza parlors and restaurants. But traditional Neapolitan styles dominated.

• Modern Italian pizzas still emphasize the original thin crust, light sauce and use of fresh, regional ingredients like olive oil, basil and mozzarella cheese.

In America:

• Pizza was introduced in the early 20th century via Italian immigrants but didn’t gain widespread popularity until the mid-1900s.

• American pizza makers began experimenting with thicker crusts, more cheese, an array of toppings and different sauce styles.

• The pizza parlor and chain pizza restaurant boomed in the 1950s and 1960s, popularizing American-style pizza with the public.

• Today, American pizza encompasses a diverse range of styles, from New York to Chicago to California. Creative toppings and larger sizes are the norm.

Ultimately, no matter which style of pizza you prefer, both Italian and American pizzas bring something unique to the table. So next time you fancy a slice be sure to try out one of each!

Dough and crust variations: Italian Pizza vs American Pizza?

The dough and crust of Italian pizza differs from American pizza in several key ways:

Thickness – Italian pizza dough is rolled much thinner to create a crisp, Neapolitan-style crust. The dough can be as thin as 2-3 mm. American pizza crusts are thicker, ranging from 6-12 mm. The thicker crusts are softer and chewier.

Flour – Italian pizza dough uses “00” flour which is finely ground and high in gluten to achieve a light, airy crumb and stretchy texture. In the U.S., all-purpose flour is more common which produces a more bread-like crust.

Hydration – Italian pizza dough has a lower hydration level around 55-60% compared to American dough which is often over 65%. The lower moisture in Italian dough helps produce a crisp crust.

Baking – Italian pizza is baked at very high temperatures (400-550°F) for just a few minutes. This achieves the thin, charred crust. American pizza is baked at lower temps (300-450°F) for longer to allow the thick dough to cook through.

Ingredients – Italian pizza dough keeps ingredients simple with flour, water, yeast and salt. American doughs may include oil, sugar and other additives for flavor and texture.

As a result of these differences, Italian pizza crust emerges from the oven thin, crisp and charred around the edges. American pizza crust is thicker, softer and chewier with a puffed appearance. The baking techniques and dough formulas have evolved in different ways to suit the favored textures and styles in Italy versus the U.S. But both achieve the same purpose of cradling and carrying the chosen pizza toppings.

Comparing Italian Pizza vs American pizza sauces?

The sauce used on Italian pizza differs from American pizza sauce in several ways:

Ingredients – Italian pizza sauce tends to be simpler, using just tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, herbs and salt. The main herbs are basil and oregano. American sauce often includes additional ingredients like sugar, pepper and other spices.

Consistency – Italian sauce is lighter in consistency and more brothy. It coats the pizza without being overly thick. American sauce tends to be thicker and richer with a pasta-like consistency.

Flavor – Italian sauce has a brighter, fresher flavor from the olive oil and abundant basil. The tomatoes also tend to be fresh and high quality. American sauce has a more tangy, robust flavor from the added seasonings and longer cooking time.

Acidity – Italian pizza sauce is less acidic due to using higher quality, lower-acid tomatoes. American pizza sauce often has an acidic bite from the inclusion of diced or crushed tomatoes.

Cooking method – Italian sauce is simply crushed or diced fresh tomatoes simmered for a short time. This preserves their fresh flavors. American sauce is often cooked for a longer time to thicken it and blend the flavors.

In summary, Italian pizza sauce aims for a lighter texture, fresher flavor and nuanced herbal notes. American pizza sauce tends toward a thicker consistency, tangier flavor and more robust seasoning. While both styles achieve the purpose of complementing and adding moisture to the pizza, their distinct characteristics mirror the favored tastes in their respective culinary traditions.

Unique toppings on Italian Pizza vs American pizza?

There are some distinct differences in the types of toppings commonly found on Italian versus American pizza:

Italian pizza toppings:

• Mozzarella – The use of fresh buffalo mozzarella is signature for Italian pizza. It melts and browns beautifully.

• Olives – Black or green olives are a classic pizza topping in Italy, adding savory flavor.

• Artichokes – Artichoke hearts, either marinated or fresh, are a popular gourmet topping in Italy.

• Prosciutto – Thinly sliced Italian ham, especially prosciutto cotto, is a common pizza topping.

• Egg – A fried or soft-boiled egg is sometimes placed on top of Italian pizzas before or after baking.

American pizza toppings:

• Pepperoni – Sliced pepperoni is the quintessential American pizza topping, originally introduced by Italian immigrants.

• Sausage – Crumbled Italian sausage is a standard topping, especially in Chicago-style deep dish pizza.

• Bacon – Crisp cooked bacon bits are a popular alternative protein topping in the U.S.

• Jalapeños – Spicy chili peppers like jalapeños are a common addition, especially on western-style pizza.

• Pineapple – Tropical fruits like pineapple and mango have become standard (though controversial!) toppings.

Italian pizza toppings tend to stick closer to Mediterranean influences with herbs, cured meats and seafood. American pizza showcases a more eclectic blend of ingredients, embracing meatier options, spice and nontraditional flavors.

Pizza dining etiquette in Italy and America?

There are some key differences in pizza dining etiquette between Italy and America:

In Italy:

• Pizzas are small and meant for sharing. It’s common for 2-3 people to split one pizza.

• Knives and forks are often used to cut and eat the pizza. Hands are less common.

• Pizzas are eaten with forks and eaten bit by bit. They are not folded in half.

• Napkins are often placed on diners’ laps while eating.

• Conversation is important. Eating pizza is a social, leisurely activity.

In America:

• Large pizzas are made for individual diners or a group. They are not necessarily meant to be shared.

• Hands are primarily used to eat the pizza, though knives and forks are an option.

• Pizzas are frequently folded in half to eat like a sandwich.

• Napkins are often placed directly on the table, not on laps.

• The focus is more on the food itself and less on socializing. Eating is straightforward.

Italian pizza dining etiquette focuses more on sharing, proper table manners and socializing. Pizzas are treated as a communal dish to be savored. In contrast, American pizza etiquette tends toward a more casual, hands-on experience where pizza is treated as an individual meal or snack.

Regional pizza variations in Italy and the US?

There are many regional variations of pizza within both Italy and the United States:

In Italy:

• Neapolitan – The original style from Naples with a thin, crispy crust, light tomato sauce and toppings of mozzarella, basil and olive oil. Baked at high temperatures.

• Roman – A thicker crust that is folded and baked in a deep pan. Often topped with artichokes and prosciutto.

• Sicilian – A thick, round crust baked in a large pan. Toppings include eggplant, ricotta cheese and sardines.

• Calabrian – A flatbread-like crust topped with spicy peppers, sausage and smoked scamorza cheese.

In the United States:

• New York – A thin crust with an oiled hand-tossed dough. Features prominent “char” and large slices. Known for cheese-heavy toppings.

• Chicago – Deep-dish and stuffed styles in deep-pan crusts. Loaded with ingredients in a casserole-like pizza.

• California – Known for non-traditional toppings like avocado, curry chicken and BBQ shrimp. Often seen on “gourmet” pizza.

• New Haven – A thin crust similar to Neapolitan but notable for using noticeable amounts of olive oil and crushed red pepper flakes.

While there are similarities across regional variations based on availability of ingredients, each style has adaptations that reflect local tastes, traditions and immigrant influences.

Wine and beer pairings for Italian Pizza vs American pizza?

There are some ideal wine and beer pairings for both Italian and American pizzas:

For Italian Pizza:

Wine – A medium-bodied red wine like Sangiovese, Italy’s native grape, works well. The tannins pair with the tomato sauce and mozzarella while the acidity cuts through the fattiness. Other options include Nebbiolo, Dolcetto and Montepulciano.

Beer – An Italian lager like Peroni or Moretti complements the simple flavors of an authentic Neapolitan pizza. The crisp, light-bodied beer does not overpower the lighter tomato sauce and fresh toppings.

For American Pizza:

Wine – A fuller-bodied red like a California Cabernet Sauvignon works well with the richer, meatier toppings. The fruit-forward notes in the wine complement pepperoni and sausage. A Zinfandel is also a good match.

Beer – An American pale ale offers balance and complexity to pair with the bolder flavors in American pizza. The citrusy, lightly hoppy beer stands up to the thicker crust and more cheesy toppings. An IPA is another suitable option.

In both cases, the goal is to find wines and beers that complement – but do not overwhelm – the primary flavors of the pizza itself. Lighter, mid-weight options work best for Italian pizza while fuller varieties match the richer, heartier nature of American pizza. In general, reds with medium to full body and medium acidity offer the best balance for pairing with cheese pizza options overall. Pairings ultimately come down to personal preference, so experiment to find what works for your taste.

Making authentic Italian pizza vs American pizza at home: tips and tricks?

Making authentic Italian and American pizzas at home can be intimidating, but there are plenty of tips and tricks that make it easier. Here are some key points to help you craft the perfect pizza.

For Italian-style pizzas:

Start with a thin crust – this is essential for getting a crispy texture when cooking in an oven or on a hot pizza stone.

Use fresh ingredients – tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, basil leaves and olive oil should all be added at the end so that they don’t cook too quickly.

Bake in an extremely hot oven – temperatures near 500F will ensure the pizza gets cooked through while creating those desirable crisp edges.

Cook quickly – thinner crusts need less time in the oven than thick ones, so keep an eye out for golden brown spots throughout your pizza which indicate it’s done!

For American style pizzas:

Select a thick dough recipe – allowing it to rest before forming into your desired shape helps create that airy yet chewy texture associated with this regional style of pie.

Precook your toppings– depending on what type of topping you plan to use (meats, vegetables), precooking them ahead of time will help ensure they have enough time to cook through in the oven.

Use a blend of cheeses– American pies require more cheese than Italian pizzas, so opt for mozzarella and cheddar as a base before adding additional varieties such as Parmesan or ricotta.

Allow your pie to cool – let your pizza rest for several minutes after pulling it from the oven – this helps to ensure that all the flavors have a chance to meld together properly.

By following these tips and tricks, you can create delicious Italian and American pizzas at home with ease!

Popular Italian Pizza vs American pizza chains and local pizzerias?

Popular Italian Pizza Chains:

• Sorbillo – A famous Neapolitan pizzeria in Naples, Italy with locations across the country. Known for thin-crust pies with classic toppings.

• Rossopomodoro – An upscale chain serving Naples-style pizza along with Italian antipasti and wine. Locations across Europe.

• Fratelli la Bufala – Specializes in pizza made with fresh buffalo mozzarella, authentic Neapolitan style. Chains across Italy.

Popular American Pizza Chains:

• Domino’s – The largest pizza chain in the U.S. with over 16,000 locations worldwide. Serves traditional American pan pizza.

• Pizza Hut – Another huge chain with over 15,000 locations globally. Offers a wide variety of pizza crusts and toppings.

• Papa John’s – Focuses on freshness and claims to use higher-quality ingredients. Has over 5,000 locations in over 40 countries.

Popular Local Italian Pizzerias:

• Flour and Salt (Boston) – Uses Italian techniques to make wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas.

• Pizzana (Los Angeles) – Focuses on authenticity with fresh, handmade mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes.

Popular Local American Pizzerias:

• Pat’s Pizza (Denver) – Popular neighborhood pizzeria with thin-crust, pane ripiena and grandma-style slices.

• Lou Malnati’s (Chicago) – Famous for its signature deep-dish pizza with a buttery, flaky crust.

Both countries feature global chains serving large volumes of customers alongside beloved independent, neighborhood pizzerias focused on quality and authenticity. While chain pizza tends toward more standardized versions, local pizzerias often showcase unique interpretations and regional adaptations of the classic dish.


there’s gold in both Italian and American pizza. Exploring both styles will expose you to different techniques, ingredient combinations and levels of simplicity versus abundance. Whether you order a whole pie or just one slice, the food of heaven awaits your appetite. Now go enjoy some pizza!

Read more:Pizza Sauce vs Marinara: What are the differences?


What is the difference between Italian pizza vs American pizza?

The main difference between Italian pizzas and American pizzas is the crust: Italian pizzas have thin, crunchy crusts while American pies have thick, fluffy doughs. Additionally, when it comes to toppings, Italian pizzas use simple ingredients like tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and basil while American slices are more elaborate with multiple kinds of cheese and a variety of proteins such as pepperoni or sausage added on top.

Is it hard to make your own pizza at home?

Making your own pizza at home can be easy if you know what kind of pizza you are trying to make – whether that’s an Italian-style pie or an American slice. Start by finding a good recipe for either style and then preparing all your ingredients before you get started cooking; for example, if you’re using meats or vegetables as topping then pre-cook them ahead of time so they will have enough time to cook through in the oven. Lastly don’t forget to let it rest after pulling from the oven – this helps ensure all flavors meld together properly!

What type of cheeses can I use on my pizza?

Most pizzas are usually topped with mozzarella cheese, however you can also experiment with other cheeses such as ricotta, Gorgonzola, Parmesan and even feta for a delicious twist! If you’re making an American-style pizza then adding multiple kinds of cheese is sure to be a hit – just make sure not to overwhelm the pie by using too many different types. With the right combination of ingredients, your homemade pizza will be a tasty success!

What is the best way to bake a pizza?

The best way to bake a pizza is in an oven preheated between 450°F to 500°F for 12-15 minutes. Depending on the type of crust and topping you are using, the baking time can vary so be sure to check it frequently during cooking. If you’re making a thinner Italian-style pizza then bake at a lower temperature for less time; if your pie is thicker with lots of cheese and toppings then cook it at a higher temperature for longer. Once finished, let your homemade pizza rest before serving – this allows all the flavors to meld together perfectly!

What else should I keep in mind when making my own pizza?

Besides following good recipes and adjusting temperatures and times as needed, another important tip is to use fresh ingredients whenever possible – this will make a huge difference in the taste of your pizza. Additionally, use good quality olive oil for drizzling on top as this adds a delicious flavor to the crust and helps it stay crispy! Lastly, don’t be afraid to experiment with different ingredients – you can create some really amazing pizzas by adding unique flavors like truffle oil or pesto sauce. With a little bit of practice and creativity, you’ll soon be an expert at crafting the perfect slice!

Is it better to use fresh or store-bought pizza dough when making your own pie?

Both fresh and store-bought pizza dough can be used for making pizzas, however it is generally considered better to use fresh homemade dough as this allows you full control over the ingredients and flavor of your pie. When using store bought crusts, make sure to read the label carefully before buying in order to get an idea of what is included in the mix and also so you can adjust accordingly when preparing your toppings (for example if there are already spices in the mix then you might want to reduce or omit them from other ingredients).

What temperatures should I preheat my oven at for different kinds of homemade pizzas?

This will depend on whether you are making Italian-style thin crust or American thick crust pies – traditional Italian pizzas require lower temperatures (400 °F – 425 °F) while American style slices need higher heat for longer cooking times (450°F – 500°F). Additionally, if your pizza has a thicker base then keep an eye on it during cooking as the cook time may need to be adjusted depending on how crispy you prefer the crust. As with any recipe, practice makes perfect so don’t be afraid to experiment with different temperatures and times until you get the desired results!

Is it possible to make a delicious homemade pizza without an oven?

Yes – while an oven is certainly the best way to bake a pizza, if you don’t have access to one then there are other ways to make a tasty homemade pie. Grilling is one option – just prepare your dough as usual and preheat the grill before placing your pizza on. You may also use a skillet or even a waffle maker for cooking pizzas in – just remember that these methods will take longer than using an oven so adjust accordingly! With some patience and practice, you can make a delicious pizza without an oven!

What types of ingredients can I use to customize my homemade pizza?

The possibilities are endless when it comes to customizing your homemade pizza. Try using herbs like oregano or basil for extra flavor, different kinds of cheeses for a more gourmet pie, fresh vegetables such as mushrooms or bell peppers for added nutrition, and even unusual toppings like truffle oil or pesto sauce. Additionally you could also experiment with different types of doughs such as whole wheat or gluten-free; the sky is the limit so have fun creating your own unique masterpiece! And don’t forget – quality ingredients will always result in a better tasting pizza so don’t skimp on the ingredients!


What are some of the differences between pizza

Leave a Comment